Oh, hello cutest tooth fairy pillows ever in the history of tooth fairy pillows

If I were the tooth fairy, I would not be all fair and diplomatic with my reward system. No ma'am. I would give the most money to the toothless child who lured me in with the cutest tooth fairy pillow and made the biggest production out of the whole lost tooth thing.

What can I say, I'm a diva tooth fairy.

That said, extra-high priority would go to the children with their former canines and bicuspids housed in the little pocket on the back of the totally adorable elephant tooth fairy pillows from Letter M Design. Designer Melody Miller makes each limited edition design from fabrics of different colors, textures and prints, along with embellishments like vintage buttons. Elephants not your kid's thing? Check out Melody's most excellent hot rod cars which also double as adorable decor.

An enclosed check-off card even helps the kid write a letter, with options like I love you better than Santa Claus. Now that's the kind of TF ego stroking that scores dollar bills. -Liz

Congratulations to Stephanie S, lucky winner of the elephant tooth fairy pillow!

Share this story

Pin

More in LivingView all picks →

Linen sheet sets from Parachute, Quince and Peacock Alley

The best linen sheets for 2026, from a $144 starter set to a splurge

How Parachute, Quince and Peacock Alley linen sheets compare on price, feel and what comes in the box, from a $144 starter set to a splurge.

Collage of popular Etsy gifts including a cat ear onyx ring, turquoise earrings, a raccoon D&D sticker, name crayons, pottery mugs, a red houseplant, cryptid ornaments and a leather photo keychain

What's selling on Etsy this week: 29 gifts shoppers are buying right now

The Etsy finds shoppers actually bought through our links lately: handwriting bracelets, name crayons, D&D raccoon stickers and cryptid ornaments.

grove co

More than cleaning supplies—eco-friendly homecare from Grove Co.

The offering is practical, useful, and subtly elevates daily routines.