AppleWhite tooth fairy pillow: homemade cottage

A tooth fairy pillow where any incisor would be happy to take up temporary residence.

When you have a kid losing a tooth, whether it's the first or the fifteenth, you know how special it can be. Maybe that's why I've always had a thing for tooth fairy pillows, and the lovely, affordable handmade ones from AppleWhite on Etsy just made me get excited for my youngest to start turning her beliefs into dollar bills. (Yes, our tooth fairy offers a dollar. Just one. I know she can probably get kicked out of Brooklyn for that, but tough.) The pillows are shaped like the sweetest cottages, homes, and even teepees, should you have a child who prefers something a little less "pretty." What I think kids will love best though is the tiny secret door with a tiny pocket inside containing a little poem to leave for old TF.   Oh who am I kidding; what they'll love best is the proof in the morning that magic does exist. Still, the pillows are  close second. Find lovely handmade tooth fairy pillows at AppleWhite on Etsy. For $5 you can also have them personalized in one of three fonts. For more tooth fairy traditions and ideas, we have lots!

Also selling now

More popular picks people are buying right now.

More in LivingView all picks →

teacher gifts they will love

17 Teacher Gifts They'll Actually Use (and Love) This Holiday Season

Thoughtful teacher gifts for the holidays, from under-$15 thank-yous to class group gifts: treats, desk upgrades, cozy splurges and practical classroom picks.

2026 Advent Calendars

Cool Mom Picks Holiday Gift Guide: Best 2026 Advent Calendars for Adults

Adult advent calendars include chocolates, puzzles, Dolly Parton gifts, wine, and grown-up toys.

grove co

More than cleaning supplies—eco-friendly homecare from Grove Co.

The offering is practical, useful, and subtly elevates daily routines.