All picks have been editorially determined by our staff. There has been no compensation for inclusion in this guide. 

This guide contains affiliate links and some purchases help support our own small business at no additional costs to you.. 

All discount codes expired 2018

For more up-to-date discounts and gift ideas, please visit our 2019 holiday gift guide or 2020 small business holiday gift guide

4 Things Personalized Tote Bag

Don’t you want to make like 100 of these?

Personalized Cameo Family Portrait by Shelly Klein

Gorgeous, modern interpretation of a family portrait, whatever your family looks like.

Totally Custom Xbox Controller

Right down to the color of the buttons. So fun!

Gold-Filled Silhouette Locket

A truly special gift for a special mom, grandma, aunt or godmother.

Custom Mix Tape Pillow

Just so you can say, “here, honey…I made you a mix tape.”

Personalized Pewter Christmas Tree Ornament

Lovely keepsake at a fantastic price.

Personalized Ombre Frost Modern Christmas Stockings

An initial or name for everyone on the nice list from a favorite Etsy shop. These stockings were even a Spawned podcast Cool Pick of the Week!

Personalized Coffee Travel Mug

Considering the size, try “Caffeinated AF”

Custom Engraved Urban Decay Vice Lipstick

More than 100 colors. And uh, does “KEEP YOUR HANDS OFF, KIDS” fit?

Custom T-shirt From Your Child’s Artwork

Your kid will be thrilled, and these guys do absolutely fantastic work.

Custom Cursive Word Necklace

Choose a name or meaningful word up to 8 letters and Peggy will custom create a special necklace in 14k gold-filled or sterling.

Personalized Unicorn Journal

For magical thinking.

Custom Embroidery Hoop Art Kit From Your Photo

Send this talented artist a favorite pic, she’ll help you get crafty with it.

Custom Solidwool Photo Calendar

Really sweet photo gift for grandparents, teachers, or all the cousins.

Child’s Signature on Custom Pendant or Keychain

A lot of artists do this now, but she’s the original — and her work is spectacular. And fast!

Personalized Ballerina Ceramic Ornament

Lots of cool options at this shop. Make it a tradition and get a new one each year.

Monogrammed Coach Duffel

If only for yourself. Oof — gorgeous.

Rewriteable Twitter T-Shirt

The ultimate personalized tee: Use a wipeable marker to “tweet” something new after every wash. #Covfefe

Personalized Wooden Skittles Set

Beautiful baby room decor turned fun toddler plaything.

Personalized Stacking Rings

The more the merrier. In fact, you can put that on a ring.

Family Faces Photo Sticker Book

Amazing personalized gift for cousins or multiple kids.

Personalized Moana Converse

The shoes to help her know the way.

Custom Misheard Lyrics Coasters

Hold me closer, Tony Danza…

Custom Map Vacuum-Insulated Travel Cup

From any city that you wish you could take with you all the time.

Personalized Darth Vader Stocking

Come to the Dark Side. It’s filled with toys!

Personalized Faux-Fur Unicorn Baby Rocker

Come on, who didn’t dream of having their very own unicorn?

Personalized Peg Doll Family Ornaments

A handmade heirloom from a real artist. Wow, the detail.

Personalized LOVE Sculpture

For your sweetheart.

Monogrammed Leather Jewelry Case

Filling it is up to you. (But do it!)

Big Deal Personalized Family Pillow

The family that brags together…

Custom Hand-Painted Funko POP Figure

No, I’m Batman.

Custom Converse

Available in kids and adult sizes. (Hint hint)

Custom Photo Mug

So many great options at really cool prices.

Personalized Jigsaw Puzzles for Kids

Sweet custom gift that makes a big impression without a big budget.

Custom Pet Plush by Petsies

What an absolutely sweet way to remember a best friend.

 Be sure to visit our 2020 Small Business Holiday Gift Guide
which helps support dozens of indie shops, makers and artists with the best gifts for everyone on your list.

See our 2021 Holiday Gift Guide here

And don't miss our guide to 50+ of the coolest gifts for kids under $50.