Your teen's wish list says "anything from Sephora," your sister swears by Ulta, and both stores have a wall of holiday gift sets right now. So which one do you actually go to?
Our answer for 2026: Ulta if you want the best price on gift sets this week, since they're up to 45% off online through November 21. Sephora if you want sets only Sephora sells, like rhode's $38 Pocket Pair.
Sephora vs. Ulta: which is better for gift sets?
For discounts on gift sets, Ulta. Its early deals take up to 45% off gift sets online through November 21, and its Black Friday sale starts online that night at 8 p.m. CT, then in stores November 22. Cyber Monday deals run online from November 29 through December 1.
For exclusive sets, Sephora. Its app early access, with free sample bags, runs November 21 and 22. Cyber Week runs November 23 through 30, with a different group of brands at 30% off each day, and the Black Friday sale starts November 26 at 6 p.m. PT.
Both rewards programs are free to join, so sign up at both before the sales start.
Sephora vs. Ulta holiday sales, 2026
01Ulta Beauty gift sets
Ulta Beauty
Gift sets up to 45% off online through Nov 21, per Ulta's announced early deals
Go here first if the gift sets are already on your list and you just want them cheaper. The early deals end November 21, and the Black Friday sale starts online that same night at 8 p.m. CT. Store and online start times differ, so check the app instead of driving over at 8.
02Sephora gift sets
Sephora
Cyber Week Nov 23–30; app early access Nov 21–22, checked Nov 17
Sephora wins on the sets you can't get anywhere else, like rhode and Sephora's own Favorites kits. Its deals are spread out: free sample bags for app shoppers November 21 and 22, then a different set of brands at 30% off each day. That's great if your teen's favorite brand gets a day, and annoying if it doesn't.
Sephora gift sets we'd give a teen or tween
03rhode Pocket Pair Limited Edition Lip + Cheek Set
Sephora · $38 ($45 value) at Sephora, checked Nov 17
The teen who's been begging for rhode gets the two things everyone wants from it: a Pocket Blush and a Peptide Lip Tint, in a matched color pair. It's only at Sephora. Heads-up if she's sensitive to scent: the lip tint has a sweet one.
04Summer Fridays The Lip Butter Balm Minis - Pink Set
Sephora · $25 at Sephora, checked Nov 17
Four flavors of Summer Fridays' Lip Butter Balm in one box: Birthday Cake, Strawberry Soft Serve, Pink Guava and Cherry. Split it up and you've got four stocking stuffers, or a gift for four friends. They're minis, though, at 0.16 ounces each, so they'll get used up faster than you'd expect.
05Sephora Favorites Holiday Must-Haves Value Set
Sephora · $25 ($72 value) at Sephora, checked Nov 17
For a tween who's new to makeup, this $25 box is a low-risk way to try five big names: Benefit brow gel, a LANEIGE lip serum, Peace Out pimple patches, a Rare Beauty liquid blush and YSL mascara. Only the LANEIGE lip serum is full size. The other four are minis.
06Beauty of Joseon Day Dew Mini Keychain Set
Sephora · $11 at Sephora, checked Nov 17
Sunscreen as a gift sounds very mom, we know. But this one comes as two minis with a beaded keychain to clip on a backpack, and it's only at Sephora, which is half the appeal for a teen. Each tube is 0.33 ounces, about right for a gym bag and not much more.
Before you shop
Sale dates and prices were last checked on November 17, 2026. Holiday deals change fast, so confirm the price on the store's site before you buy.
For every store's sale dates, see our Black Friday hub and our Ulta Black Friday guide. For more gifts, try the teen gift guide.
Reader Q&A
Holiday gifts questions, answered
Sephora vs. Ulta: which is better?
For gift sets this holiday, Ulta has the bigger discounts, up to 45% off online through November 21. Sephora is better for sets you can't find anywhere else, like rhode's Pocket Pair and its own Sephora Favorites kits.
Sephora vs. Ulta: which is cheaper?
It depends on the week. Ulta's gift sets are cheaper through November 21. During Sephora's Cyber Week, November 23 through 30, the brands on sale that day are 30% off, which can beat Ulta for that brand.
When do Ulta gift sets go on sale?
They already are: up to 45% off online through November 21. Ulta's Black Friday sale then starts online November 21 at 8 p.m. CT and in stores November 22.
Which Sephora gift sets are worth it?
Look at the value printed next to the price. The Sephora Favorites Holiday Must-Haves set is $25 for a $72 value, though four of its five items are minis. The rhode Pocket Pair is $38 for a $45 value and is only at Sephora.