Personalized Father’s Day gifts are always some of our favorite to track down, but this year we kept an eye out for personalized gifts for dad that were a bit off the beaten track. So no mugs. Just these cool custom gift ideas.
Don’t miss our huge Father’s Day Gift Guide Giveaway! Details below
Personalized Keychain for Dad
We’re not sure if there’s anything sweeter than this sterling keychain personalized from your very own kiddo. The more imperfect the handwriting, the more perfect the gift. ($48+ from Cherished Sentiments)
Custom Pocket Square
We love that this pocket square is actually round. This would be so great with a vintage family photo, a pic of a hero of his, the adorable new baby, or even his own father. There’s a handy fold guide on site too–print it out and include it in the card. ($69 at Sebastien Grey Clothiers)
Custom Portrait From an Artist
We see a lot of custom portrait options, but few from real artists. There are lots to choose from at this site, but for dads, we especially love Ali Al-Sumayin‘s minimalist, modern take on portraits and illustrator Danilo Agutoli, whose work has been featured in magazines like Wired. Turnaround time starts at 2 weeks. ($960+ at Fabulous Noble)
Personalized Father’s Day Photo Card
It’s nice to find a service that lets you buy just one card. Choose from a daughter or a son. While you can’t personalized the poem, it is pretty sweet. ($4.95, Ruva Cards)
Personalized Beer Glasses
These cool British-style pub glasses can accomodate a family name, hometown and year. Cheaper than buying your own pub.($49.95/set at Red Envelope)
Custom Guitar Strap
Get a rock n’ roll dad pumped by uploading your own photos on this custom strap and adding your own text. All the fonts are extremely cool, of course. ($59+ at Strap Graphics)
Custom Engraved Beer Carrier
Not sure why dads get all the luck–we’d love one of these too. It’s handmade out of Eugene, Oregon and it’s pretty darn cool. ($49.99 at FunMade Products)
Monogrammed Locket Cufflinks
Can’t pick between a monogram and a photo gift? These elegant cufflinks let you do both, perfect for a father, stepfather, or grandpa. Bring back French cuffs, please! ($99.99 at Red Envelope)
Not that he doesn’t love the way the kids make up their own lyrics to the Spongebob theme song, but this goes a step further–submit special interests, hobbies, people to be mentioned in the song and any other requests including musical genre. ($249+ from Your Personal Song)
Personalized Tabasco Gallon Jug
If your dad has everything there’s no way he has this. Bonus: You will never have to buy Tabasco at the store ever again. ($44.95 from Country Store)
Love this sentiment so much. Pick your color and add your signature at the bottom, all for a great price. ($19, Prints by Christine)
EXTRA-COOL: WIN IT! We’re so excited to give away a Father’s Day gift pack valued at more than $550!
1. Jack Spade Canvas Messenger Bag 2. MOUTH World’s Greatest Dad Gourmet Basket 3. Complete Game of Thrones Season 1 Blu-Ray Collection 4. Daddy Keychain by Lisa Leonard 5. Dove Men+Care Gift Pack for skin, face, body and hair 6.Dad’s Book of Awesome Projects 7. Native Union Switch Bluetooth Speaker
I think the custom keychain is my favorite. Thanks for such a great list!
Love, love, love the personalized keychain!
I love the beer carrier! And also the cufflinks…I guess the beer carrier more for me and the cufflinks for him 🙂
Gotta love the custom portraits. Amazing!
Those personalized beer glasses are awesome!
really love the personalized keychain. that’s awesome!
Love the personal song idea, so creative and sentimental
LOVE the personalized keychain with kids’ writing!
My favorite item is the Custom Father’s Day Art Print…it’s very personal and memorable.
LOVE the kiddo inscribed key chain!!
I love the customized song and the customized portrait. I also like the personalized keychain!
I love it all! MOUTH World’s Greatest Dad Gourmet Basket is probably my favorite.
The keychain is so perfect! Our little ones love leaving us little love notes and artwork all the time – this is a great way to always keep it with us!
I really like the personalized key chain.
Love all the gift ideas!
I really like the engraved beer carrier. Great ideas!
I like the custom engraved beer carrier! My husband brews his own, so it would be a perfect gift for him!
My favorite is the Tabasco because my hubby LOVES his hot sauce!
I like the personalized beer glasses the best!
That key chain is adorable, definitely my favorite.
The personalized song is a fantastic idea – my husband loves to play the piano!
I LOVE the custom art print for Dad
love the messenger bag!!
My favorite is the personalized keychain!
I love the locket cuff links
I like the personalized art print. How lovely and sentimental.
MOUTH World’s Greatest Dad Gourmet Basket!
love the locket cufflinks!
love the cufflinks!
I love the personalized Tabasco jug! Thanks for the chance to win.
I like the cufflinks!!!
Love the custom guitar strap. Perfect for my artist son to give his dad (who just received a guitar for his 50th Birthday)!
Love the personalized keychain. Thanks for the giveaway!
My hubby would LOVE the Game of Thrones dvds!
I love the pint glasses. I think I’ll get those for him for his birthday!
Definitely the personalized keychain–that’s adorable!
The custom portrait is cool. A little more $ than I have to spend, though.
What’s not to love about a gallon of tabasco!
Love the fun locket cuff links. So clever!
You could easily make the “dad” portraits yourself! Projector with an image on transparency and trace on canvas!! 🙂
Love the beer glasses!!!
The personalized keychain would be a winner in my husband’s book.
The keychain for sure!
I like the personalized beer caddy and the beer glasses.
The keychain is an awesome idea too, but I’ll have to wait until my kids are a little older.
I love the keychain and the print!
Love the custom beer glasses!
I love the beer carrier! I know my SO would love to carry his beers to a guys night in this case.
Love the personalized key chain!
pretty sure my pop deserves a custom portrait from an artist.
Love the personalized song. My husband makes up songs all the time; he would love that!
Game of thrones DVD!!
I love the custom portrait, you can’t get more unique than that!
My favorite is the Custom Portrait.
The Personalized Bee Carrier Is Really Cool! Totally My Favorite!
I like the art print, the last one.
I like the custom beer glasses
I love the personalized key chain, so sweet.
I love the keychain! My kids would be so happy to give this to him!
LOVE the keychain.
Love the personalized keychain! How sweet!
Love the personalized beer glasses!
I love the handwritten message keychains! All of these are awesome.
The tabasco sauce! Perfect gift for my dad who believes everything should be covered in Tabasco.
The custom beer glasses are great!
Love the Monogrammed Locket Cufflinks
Dad’s perspective here… the Tabasco is the best. It’s practical. Runner up are the portraits. Good to make a guy feel like he looks cooler than he feels.
I love, love, love the “to the world” sign!
I like the personalized beer glasses.
Well, I love the keychain, but I know someone who would really like the DVDs! All great ideas!
I love the personalized beer glasses. I think daddy would too.
Beer glasses could work for lots of occasions!
I love the handwritten message key chain, but my husband would love the beer carrier best. These are all really cute ideas!
Love the personalized song, my husband is a musician and would love something like that!
Love the locket cufflinks (I love French cuffs)!
The custom portrait is so great.
The personalized song is wonderful!
I am really digging the Custom Father’s Day Art Print! He’d love it from my son.
The personalized keychain is adorable!
love the beer carrier
The keychain with handwriting is the best! Plus the project book to do things with the kids.
I love the handwritten keychain it is darling.
The etched personalized keychain is so sweet! Capturing a name or a sweet message from a certain date and time would be a perfect Father’s or Mother’s Day gift…
The keychain is the cutest!
I love the Custom Engraved Beer Carrier – great for summer BBQs.
Love the personalized glasses.
Love the keychain and the book!!
He would love any of these gifts that the kids picked out!
I think it would be nice to have a custom art print in his office.
To remind him how valued he is while he is slaving away. Just to make him smile and feel loved! Because we do!
It’s a tough call between the custom beer carrier and the personalised pint glasses.
The Tabasco gallon jug is neat (and immensely practical)!
The keychain is my favorite.
I love the Personalized Keychain for Dad, I know that this is actually something that He would use and cherish
Custom Portrait from an artist is wonderful.
The personalized beer glasses would be great!!!
I love the personalized keychain. It is adorable.
The diy book would be great for him to bond with his girls and the keychain is absolutely precious!
Love the personalized keychain.
I love the key chain in the kids writing!! I’m definitely looking into doing this 🙂
Tabasco for the win!
That personalized keychain is the best!!
Love the Father’s Day Art Print! Awesome!
My favorite item is the Custom Father’s Day Art Print!
I love the custom portrait from an artist. My dad’s got pretty much everything and I think he’d enjoy an artist’s persepective. Plus, he’d have fun trying to think of a good pose to be forever memorialized.
My favorite is the gallon of Tabasco!! My husband puts Tabasco on everything. He is in Afghanistan and so I feel like he could actually use that type of Father’s Day gift! I just had our first child together 10 weeks ago so is important to me he gets a daddy’s day gift out there!
Love the personalized keychain!
I love, love, love the art print at the very end. But the beer carrier is pretty cool and would probably be my husband’s favorite! 🙂
The ginormous Tabasco jug is hilarious! He’d get such a kick out of it!
I like the key chain.
Custom Engraved Beer Carrier. He would love it considering a night out for him is having a few beers with his best friend in the backyard. 🙂
I love the customized keychain!
I really like Ali Al-Sumayin’s minimalist portraits…. I got a kick picturing my bald husband as two bushy eyebrows floating over his favorite shirt!
I really like the personalized beer glasses from Red Envelope
I love all the items featured, but my favorite has to be the personalized key chain by Lisa Leonard. Our daughter is really starting to talk right now and she has a few funny phrases that would be perfect to engrave on this key chain for my husband as the perfect useable keepsake. Thank you for offering such a great prize package! Hope I win!
My husband would get a kick out of the jug of Tabasco sauce! What a fun idea!
Custom Engraved Beer Carrier.
Ali Al-Sumayin’s portraits are amazing. I love them.
I love love love the custom keychain! But he might like the gallon of hot sauce better…
I really like the personalized keychain for dad
i love the custom guitar strap. this year, our daughter is giving my husband a custom guitar pick. she’s only 20 months old and already has two guitars that she and her dad play together [an old bass that she loves to strum and bang on, and a little martin backpack guitar that is registered to her, and that she strums while dad holds the strings down. 🙂 ]. the strap would be a perfect complement!
I loved the key chain!
I like the Custom Father’s Day Art Print
The custom Father’s Day art print is my favorite, I love written emotion; the print says so much with so little.
I love the custom Father’s Day art print. How great is that? You guys have the greatest finds.
Love the keychain. Perfect for our little one to give daddy.
I am in love with the Personalized Beer Glasses. Thanks for the awesome giveaway 🙂
fattybumpkins at yahoo dot com
Love the beer glasses.
The guitar strap is my favorite
Love love love the Custom Father’s Day Art Print!
Custom Engraved Beer Carrier will have him beaming with pride at the next neighborhood get together.
I love the custom art print! Very affordable.
The jack spade messenger bag is the perfect gift! This is a chic (and manly) way to have a daddy diaper bag!
Love the Custom Oclet Square.
I love the keychain because my son is just learning to write.
The personalized keychain is pretty sweet! 🙂
I love the keychain. I know he would love the Game of Thrones box set. Love ask the ideas!
I love the keychain in the kids’ writing. So adorable! But, I may have to wait until my 2 year old can write.
Absolutely love the beer glasses and personalized Tabasco! So clever!
Amazing ideas! Love them all! I would have to go with the guitar strap. My husband spends hours playing for our daughter. She can’t get enough. The strap is a perfectly meaningful dad’s day gift. Thanks, Cool Mom!
I love the custom father’s day art print!
The beer carrier is super cool!
Custom beer glasses are way cool!
My very favorite is the custom key chain. Sentimental, yet functional!
Love the jug of Tobasco! This may be the one thing my Dad doesn’t have!
The tabasco sauce would be perfect. He puts the stuff in everything from eggs to beef stew.
The personalized beer carriers will be a perfect gift for a certain home brewer that I know!
I am in love with the oh-so-personalized keychain. That is something that will last for YEARS and would mean more than any store-bought gift! Love it!!!
Love the custom portrait the most! But the personalized key chain is a close second!
The key chain is fantastic, but think of this: after he finally finishes all that Tabasco Sauce, your family could start a jug band! Flavorful food and family bonding in one bright red jug!
Love the personalized song! Great idea!
The custom keychain definitely is my favorite!
I love the key chain as a keepsake, and the personalized beer glasses for my beer making husband!
I absolutely LOVE the Key chain!!
Personalized beer glasses
I love the book of daddy projects!
The personalized Tabasco gallon jar.
Love the beer carrier and pub glasses!
I love the custom keychain. Simple and sweet!
The custom keychain is the best!
I love the personalized key chain although the custom beer carrier is more my husbands style.
Great ideas on this site!
I love the art print. So sweet.
I love the custom keychain!!
Love the key chain!
I like the personalized beer glass
The song. Nothing says it better than a song.
My favorite is the custom print. Whe my little one can write the key chain would be nice
Love the keychain!!
The beer carrier is super rad.
LOVE the personalized key chain.
I absolutely LOVE the personalized keychain, I wish my daughter could write already!
I adore the personalized keychain b/c we are really working hard to encourage our 5 year old daughter to write more. It’s something that is very hard for her, so she often avoids doing it. But, that’s the reason it would mean even more to my husband in particular b/c it would be a reminder of how hard she worked at doing something special- just for him b/c she loves him so much!
I love the custom 6 pack holder!
Love the key chain as well!!
The custom guitar strap. How fun would that be for a musician dad!! Thanks.
Love the keychain!!
LOVE THE CUFF LINKS, AS WELL AS, THE CUSTUM ART PRINT (VERY AFFORDABLE) GREAT GIFT IDEAS, THANKS!
Love, love,love the shrinky dink tie pins! So many fantastic ideas in this list…
Personalized key chain.
For me it is a tie between the key chain and the custom fathers day art print. This list is so much more creative then the traditional fathers day gift lists, love it!
the Personalized TABASCO Gallon Jugs is my favorite
I love the pocket square! So classy!
I LOVE the personalized beer glasses and carrier. Perfect for our homebrewing dad! 🙂
I absolutely love the Custom Father’s Day Art Print. It’ll show my dad that no matter how I am now, he’s always going to be dad and to me, he is in fact the world. Thanks for these cool ideas!
That beer carrier is super awesome, but I do love the sentiment on the art print. Thanks!
Key Chain is my favorite
I love the personalized keychain for Dad! Too cute!
I LOVE the Father’s Day art print. Brought a tear to my eye when reading.
Super Loved the keychain!
inalak at msn dot com
love the custom keychain
I love the custom key-chain!
The Jack Spade Canvas Messenger Bag is great.
I love the daddy is my hero keychain
I love those locket cufflinks!!
Loved the cufflinks!
I love the monogrammed locket cufflinks :O)
I love the keychain!
The custom guitar strap is cool!
I like the keychain with personalized handwriting. Very cute.
I love the print and the portraits. He would want the Tabasco.
the personalized beer glasses! so cool!
LOVE the Tabasco… although… I’m not sure who would love it more. Me or Dad. hahah 🙂
Love the personalized photo card, may just have to frame that as art!
Definitely the keychain!
Keychain is the perfect keepsake.
I really like the Father’s Day Art Print!
sazzyfrazz at gmail dot com
Both examples of the Custom Portrait From an Artist were great!
My hubs would really enjoy the Native Union Switch Bluetooth Speaker!
I love the Personalized Beer Glasses
The keychain is my fav!
The Personalized Beer Glasses are perfect (and so is the personalized keychain…couldn’t decide between them :))
i just loved the Custom Father’s Day Art Print. The quote is just so sweet.
The Tabasco Gallon Jug rocks!
I love the personalized beer glasses!
love the personalized tabasco jug! who doesn’t need that?
Those cufflinks are great. He’s been wanting a new pair, and I love that they could have a little secret inside.
I love the personalized key chain!
The personalized keychain is the best!
I love the personalized key chain! Aloha!
I think beer glasses or beer carrier.
That beer carrier is too cool!
I adore the Jack Spade bag & know my husband will too!
i love game of thrones and dove plus men care!
The personalized keychain.
Custom Father’s Day Art Print
I love the idea of a custom portrait!
The food is the best.
The pocket square is perfect for my husband, the engineer!
I LOVE the personalized keychain. Best idea ever!!!
My favorite is definitely the keychain.
Personalized Tabasco Gallon Jug
I love the keychain idea! SOOO great!
I got my dad a million different gifts and the only thing he ever used was a golf ball of the month subscription. Fickle man. I doubt he will like the headphones but maybe the booze
Love the personalized art print
Personalized Keychain for Dad
Definitely the pocket square- haven’t seen anything like it before!
Games of Thrones DVD!
The personalized keychain is my favorite, but I also loved the personalized photo card. Thanks for the great ideas!
The personalized portraits are so cool
Love the Keychain!! Too cool!
I love the print by christine….. So sweet. And the beer bottle carrier is awesome! So clever!!
The custom Portrait From an Artist is cool!
i love the custom key chain! now that my daughter writes letters to everyone all day long, i would love to get one that she writes to her dad. 🙂
The personalized keychain is awesome! My stepdaughter is always doing little drawings, and this would be a great way to forever remember a favorite one!
I love, love, love the personalized keychain!
I like the personalized key chain.
Fav, fav, fav is the personalized gallon of Tabasco! We love spicy and the Dad’s are gonna love it! Thanks for the “coolest” tip!
Ooooh, I love the personalized song! It’s super extravagant but one of those gifts that won’t gather dust or soon be forgotten 🙂 Very fun!! firstname.lastname@example.org
love love the artist sketches! but i think my husband will love the custom beer glasses and carrier more :0
I love the Portrait from an Artist.
Custom Portrait from an Artist! That is so awesome!
The pint glasses
I adore the “Customized Art Print!”
Thanks very much…
Those personal beer glasses ROCK!
The Tobasco gallon jug of course! My dad NEEDS to spice up his food 🙂
Love the beer carrier!
Love the Custom Guitar Strap
Love the Tabasco sauce!
custom portrait from an artist is amazing!! love the song idea too, but the portrait is visually stunning. thank you!
Love the personalized beer glasses! ThanKs!!
We like the Personalized Tabasco Gallon Jug !!!
My husband has a Tabasco obsession so I think the personalized Tabasco bottle is hilarious.
the custom portrait from an artist is amazing!! love the song idea too, but the portrait is visually stunning. thank you!