You got organic peanut butter in my chocolate!

You got organic peanut butter in my chocolate!

Well, wasn't I delighted to walk into my local bodega and see a brand new treat from Justin's Organic Peanut Butter staring back at me from the counter. Okay, my thighs weren't delighted, but I sure was. Move over Reese's: I love you but I'm happy to spend a little more to trade up to Justin's Organic Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups. I had to do a taste test between the milk chocolate and dark chocolate versions (I know, cry for me) and it's a toss-up. The milk chocolate has that more familiar American candy bar flavor, but zomg the dark chocolate? It's rich and delicious and perfectly bittersweet. It's nice to know the chocolate is all organic and fair trade, and in fact every single ingredient is labeled organic with the exception of the sea salt. We'll give it a pass. Plus it's made without any GMOs which is something I'm increasingly aware of these days. Did I mention delicious? I will once more. Just because. Visit Justins.com for more on their delicious (it's true!) organic nut butters and chocolate peanut butter candies. You can buy them online from the Justin's nut butter store if you're buying in bulk, find a store near you, or just visit my neighborhood. I'll show you the way.

Share this story

Pin

More in Food + RecipesView all picks →

2026 Advent Calendars

Cool Mom Picks Holiday Gift Guide: Best 2026 Advent Calendars for Adults

Adult advent calendars include chocolates, puzzles, Dolly Parton gifts, wine, and grown-up toys.

OMG, have you tried Popsmith yet?

OMG, have you tried Popsmith yet?

Popcorn has officially graduated from “movie night snack” to something we’d actually be happy putting out when friends come over. Popsmith takes the familiar salty-sweet favorite and gives it a more elevated, giftable feel—because yeah, …

Beat summer boredom with fun recipes and tools from King Arthur Baking

Beat summer boredom with fun recipes and tools from King Arthur Baking

Summer has a funny way of making tweens simultaneously bored and too busy. If you're looking for an activity that gets them off their screens, teaches a real-life skill, and just happens to end with warm cookies, King Arthur Baking is ha…