If you have daughters, if you know daughters, if you have ever bought a single Disney Princess gift for someone else’s daughters, you simply must read Cinderella Ate My Daughter: Dispatches From the Front Lines of the New Girlie-Girl Culture.
(Quick! Before you bypass the art supplies and mindlessly reach for a Tinkerbell hand mirror at the toy store.)
Be assured this is not some dogmatic, finger-wagging tome about how Ariel and Barbie are ruining our world. Using her own experiences as a feminist mother trying to come to terms with a tiara-happy daughter (I can relate!), Orenstein’s book is part lesson in gender politics, part fascinating marketing case study, and part part laugh-out-loud conversation with your very clever friend over coffee who just happens to be grappling with the same issues you are right now.
Related: 17 feminist gifts that honor our activist women friends
In Cinderella Ate My Daughter Orenstein takes you through the history of licensed marketing to girls, back to the Shirley Temple days, then hitting on milestones like the introduction of Barbie; the pseudo-empowerment of the Spice Girls; the oversexualized evil (my word) that is Bratz and all their copycatz and wannabeez; and finally, today’s world of Hanna Montana, American Girl Doll, and of course, Disney Princesses.
In other words, want to know how the heck we got to a place where 5 year-olds are wearing navel-baring shirts with double entendres on them? This book should help.
I don’t agree with every opinion–I happen to be a Tiana fan–but I do agree with about 98% of it, including Orenstein’s main point: not that princesses are bad per se, but that our girls hardly have a choice these days what with the nationwide “explosion of pink.”
What’s interesting about this book is that it doesn’t set out to offer concrete solutions, but to offer hope; my net takeaway is that when we arm ourselves with knowledge and real media savvy, we can help navigate our daughters’ worlds a little better. And more importantly, we can offer our girls a healthy, necessary counterbalance to all the commercial messages, so we can more positively influence their emotional development, self-esteem, and even chances for success in life.
In other words, don’t let your child’s values be solely determined by marketers with warehouses full of sparkly crap to sell. Who isn’t down with that?
Cinderella Ate My Daughter is not a “here’s what you should do” book, but rather, a “hey…let’s figure out what we can do” book. And I really appreciate that kind of a thought starter.
Of course the great irony of it all: The book jacket is covered in pink and sparkles. Enough so, that my 3 year-old daughter picked it up and said, “oooohhh…Mommy…can we read this tonight?”
Peggy? Let’s get coffee. Pencil in six hours or so.
Find Cinderella Ate My Daughter by Peggy Orenstein online from our affiliate Amazon
Ooh, can’t wait to read this one! Just put it on hold at my local library. I have no idea how I managed to have a daughter that loves all things sparkly and pink, but she is who she is.
As long as she keeps playing with trucks and trains, digging in dirt, and running and jumping in that princess dress I think we’ll be ok, but what do I know? She is only 2.
Peggy was featured on an episode of the Diane Rehm Show fairly recently. I am a dad of boys but was definitely fascinated by this topic.
Here is a link to the story (audio) and transcript for those interested:
https://thedianerehmshow.org/shows/2011-01-27/peggy-orenstein-cinderella-ate-my-daughter
https://thedianerehmshow.org/shows/2011-01-27/peggy-orenstein-cinderella-ate-my-daughter/transcript
I’m reading this now. It’s taking me a long time because I keep getting so aggravated I have to take breaks. I am a huge Peggy Orenstein fan…it’s the subject matter that gives me agita.
Can’t wait to read it! I happen to love all things pink and girlie girl, but I agree that girls grow up in this culture too fast.
I think an important component is for Dads (or Grandads, or Uncles, or Godfathers or… you get the picture) to be involved with their daughter’s interests. My 3yo loves her dresses and sparkly shoes and dolls, but she also loves to drive radio-controlled cars and go fishing with her Daddy. Balance is key.
Picked this up at the library, based on your recommendation. Yes, every parent of little girls should read it! Great historical information about why things are the way they are. Amazing how much influence marketing has on our kids!