If you’re looking for cool Valentine’s gifts for teens, we’re happy to present a whole bunch of the best gift finds, all supporting the real makers we love on Etsy. I mean we’ve always been the place to find unique Valentine’s gifts for everyone on your list, but this year we wanted to shine a light on the small businesses that are helping us find one of the toughest gifts to shop for: the cool Valentine’s gifts for teens that they’ll actually like.

Whether you’re shopping for your own teen, or they’re looking for a gift for a friend, we hope you find something to love. And hey —  look through our guide to our favorite Valentine’s gifts for kids on Etsy too. You may find something adorably ironic.

This post contains affiliate links and your purchases from Etsy help support our team at no additional cost to you. Thank you for your support! Top image: Conversation Heart Bath Bombs, Lensik IV

Cool Valentine’s Gifts for Teens on Etsy

Best Valentine's gifts on Etsy for Teens: Lily's Handmade adorable knit fingerless gloves
Handknit Fingerless Heart Gloves
Keep their fingers free tor texting with these fingerless gloves knit in your choice of colors from this NYC’ knitter.
($33, Lily’s Handmade)

Best Valentine's gifts on Etsy for Teens: Lensiki IV's conversation heart bath bombs
Conversation Heart Bath Bombs
These fizzy little hearts are made from just a few natural ingredients in Massachusetts, and come in three scents and colors.
($17, Lensik IV)

Best Valentine's gift for teens on Etsy: Anatomically correct chocolate heart from Farmhouse Chocolates in Vermont

Anatomically Correct Chocolate Heart 
If you’re looking for a cool Valentine’s gift for a teen with a little edge, they won’t say no to chocolate in general, but especially one that’s shaped like a real heart from this organic, fair trade Vermont Chocolatier.
($10, Farmhouse Chocolates)

Best Valentine's gifts on Etsy for Teens: Hannah Naomi's heart earrings
Delicate Hoop Heart Earrings
How pretty are these? Choose from the larger size (shown) or a much smaller one sized perfectly for tweens.
($39.48+, Hannah Naomi)

Related: Cool Valentine’s Day jewelry for women beyond the ordinary

Valentine's gifts for teens on Etsy: Wool felted ghost from Needle Ghost

Felted Valentines Ghost
Instead of a cute plushie, how about this cool handmade ghost from Rhode Island, with your choice of colored hearts? Definitely Wednesday-approved.
($28, Needle Ghost)

Best Valentine's gifts on Etsy for Teens: Hearts for Friendship LEGO heart necklace for two
BFF heart necklace
To share with a bestie, these two gender-neutral, coordinating BFF necklaces are a cool Valentine’s gift for teens who aren’t so into heart jewelry — when the pieces are separated, they look like LEGO dog tags.
($9.98+ for each half, Hearts for Friendship)

Best Valentine's gifts on Etsy for Teens: HnH Stitch coffee cozy in a dozen colors
Hand Knit Heart Coffee Cup Sleeve
Coffee-loving eens will get good use out of this reusable sleeve that can be ordered in more than a dozen colors.
Adding a coffee gift card — up to you.
($12, HnH Stitch)

Best Valentine's gifts on Etsy for Teens: Tierra Sol Studio's mini cactus in planter
Mini Cactus in Handmade Planter
Cacti are an excellent starter plant, making this tiny clay planter from this Durham studio a very cool Valentine’s gift for teens.
($25, Tierra Sol Studio)

MYO mixtape on CD that looks like vinyl! Cool custom Valentine's gifts for teens

A Custom Mixtape on CD or Casette
Since music is a teen’s love language, they might love their favorite playlist turned into a CD…that looks like an album.
Just link your playlist from Spotify or Apple Music, or send an MP3.
($32.99, Mars Mixtapes)

Best Valentine's gifts for teens on Etsy: Heart shaped hot chocolate bombs in outrageous flavors from Lovelee Cookies

A Heart-Shaped Hot Chocolate Bomb
Straight from Utah, choose salted caramel, mint chocolate, snickerdoodle, s’more… sorry, no Flamin’ Hot Cheetos flavor.
($8/ea, Lovely Cookies)

Best Valentine's gifts on Etsy for Teens: The Pink Locket's heart shaped necklace
Rose Gold Heart Necklace
For teens stepping up from kids’ jewelry, love this pretty heart pendant from a Black-owned Etsy jewelry artist. In fact, browse the shop — she has lots of sweet gift ideas worth bookmarking.
($39, The Pink Locket)

Best Valentine's gifts on Etsy for Teens: Oh So Jo Designs' Swiftie conversation heart earrings

Swiftie Heart Earrings
A cool Valentine’s gift for a tween or teen who loves Taylor Swift? Well besides tickets to her Japan tour? These conversation heart earrings. While you’re at it, find more ideas in our guide to the Best Taylor Swift gifts for fans.
($13, Oh So Jo Designs)

Best Valentine's gifts on Etsy for Teens: One27Designs' Drive Safe keychain
New Driver Keychain
Cosigned by all of us parents of new drivers, you can even personalize this heartfelt sentiment with your initial.
Or try this message from two parents, or a whole family.
($9.37, One27Designs)

Etsy gift cards for Valentine's Day

An Etsy Gift Card
Because whatever we pick out for our teens for Valentine’s Day… they will definitely want something else!
(price varies, Etsy)